Comparing the return
, rewrite
, and try_files
Directives
The two directives for general‑purpose NGINX rewrite are return
and rewrite
, and the try_files
directive is a handy way to direct requests to application servers. Let’s review what the directives do and how they differ.
The return
Directive
The return
directive is the simpler of the two general‑purpose directives and for that reason we recommend using it instead of rewrite
when possible (more later about the why and when). You enclose the return
in a server
or location
context that specifies the URLs to be rewritten, and it defines the
corrected (rewritten) URL for the client to use in future requests for
the resource.Here’s a very simple example that redirects clients to a new domain name:
server {
listen 80;
listen 443 ssl;
server_name www.old-name.com;
return 301 $scheme://www.new-name.com$request_uri;
}
The listen
directives mean the server
block applies to both HTTP and HTTPS traffic. The server_name
directive matches request URLs that have domain name www.old‑name.com. The return
directive tells NGINX to stop processing the request and immediately send code 301
(Moved
Permanently)
and the specified rewritten URL to the client. The rewritten URL uses two NGINX variables to capture and replicate values from the original request URL: $scheme
is the protocol (http or https) and $request_uri
is the full URI including arguments.For a code in the
3xx
series, the url
parameter defines the new (rewritten) URL.return (301 | 302 | 303 | 307) url;
For other codes, you optionally define a text string which appears in
the body of the response (the standard text for the HTTP code, such as Not
Found
for 404
, is still included in the header). The text can contain NGINX variables.return (1xx | 2xx | 4xx | 5xx) ["text"];
For example, this directive might be appropriate when rejecting requests that don’t have a valid authentication token:return 401 "Access denied because token is expired or invalid";
There are also a couple syntactic shortcuts you can use, such as omitting the code if it is 302
; see the reference documentation for the return
directive.(In some cases, you might want to return a response that is more complex or nuanced than you can achieve in a text string. With the
error_page
directive, you can return a complete custom HTML page for each HTTP
code, as well as change the response code or perform a redirect.)So the
return
directive is simple to use, and suitable
when the redirect meets two conditions: the rewritten URL is appropriate
for every request that matches the server
or location
block, and you can build the rewritten URL with standard NGINX variables.
The rewrite
Directive
But what if you need to test for more complicated distinctions
between URLs, capture elements in the original URL that don’t have
corresponding NGINX variables, or change or add elements in the path?
You can use the rewrite
directive in such cases.Like the
return
directive, you enclose the rewrite
directive in a server
or location
context that defines the URLs to be rewritten. Otherwise, the two directives are rather more different than similar, and the rewrite
directive can be more complicated to use correctly. Its syntax is simple enough:rewrite regex URL [flag];
But the first argument, regex
, means that
NGINX Plus and NGINX rewrite the URL only if it matches the specified
regular expression (in addition to matching the server
or location
directive). The additional test means NGINX must do more processing.A second difference is that the
rewrite
directive can return only code 301
or 302
. To return other codes, you need to include a return
directive after the rewrite
directive (see the example below).And finally the
rewrite
directive does not necessarily halt NGINX’s processing of the request as return
does, and it doesn’t necessarily send a redirect to the client. Unless
you explicitly indicate (with flags or the syntax of the URL) that you
want NGINX to halt processing or send a redirect, it runs through the
entire configuration looking for directives that are defined in the Rewrite module (break
, if
, return
, rewrite
, and set
),
and processes them in order. If a rewritten URL matches a subsequent
directive from the Rewrite module, NGINX performs the indicated action
on the rewritten URL (often rewriting it again).This is where things can get complicated, and you need to plan carefully how you order the directives to get the desired result. For instance, if the original
location
block and the NGINX
rewrite rules in it match the rewritten URL, NGINX can get into a loop,
applying the rewrite over and over up to the built‑in limit of 10 times.
To learn all the details, see the documentation for the Rewrite module. As previously noted, we recommend that where possible you use the return
directive instead.Here’s a sample NGINX rewrite rule that uses the
rewrite
directive. It matches URLs that begin with the string /download and then include the /media/ or /audio/ directory somewhere later in the path. It replaces those elements with /mp3/ and adds the appropriate file extension, .mp3 or .ra. The $1
and $2
variables capture the path elements that aren’t changing. As an example, /download/cdn-west/media/file1 becomes /download/cdn-west/mp3/file1.mp3.server {
...
rewrite ^(/download/.*)/media/(.*)\..*$ $1/mp3/$2.mp3 last;
rewrite ^(/download/.*)/audio/(.*)\..*$ $1/mp3/$2.ra last;
return 403;
...
}
We mentioned above that you can add flags to a rewrite
directive to control the flow of processing. The last
flag in the example is one of them: it tells NGINX to skip any subsequent Rewrite‑module directives in the current server
or location
block and start a search for a new location
that matches the rewritten URL.The final
return
directive in this example means that if the URL doesn’t match either rewrite
directive, code 403
is returned to the client.
The try_files
directive
Like the return
and rewrite
directives, the try_files
directive is placed in a server
or location
block. As parameters, it takes a list of one or more files and directories and a final URI:try_files file … uri;
NGINX checks for the existence of the files and directories in order
(constructing the full path to each file from the settings of the root
and alias
directives), and serves the first one it finds. To indicate a
directory, add a slash at the end of the element name. If none of the
files or directories exist, NGINX performs an internal redirect to the
URI defined by the final element (uri
).For the
try_files
directive to work, you also need to define a location
block that captures the internal redirect, as shown in the following
example. The final element can be a named location, indicated by an
initial at‑sign (@
).The
try_files
directive commonly uses the $uri
variable, which represents the part of the URL after the domain name.In the following example, NGINX serves a default GIF file if the file requested by the client doesn’t exist. When the client requests (for example) http://www.domain.com/images/image1.gif, NGINX first looks for image1.gif in the local directory specified by the
root
or alias
directive that applies to the location (not shown in the snippet). If image1.gif doesn’t exist, NGINX looks for image1.gif/, and if that doesn’t exist, it redirects to /images/default.gif. That value exactly matches the second location
directive, so processing stops and NGINX serves that file and marks it to be cached for 30 seconds.location /images/ {
try_files $uri $uri/ /images/default.gif;
}
location = /images/default.gif {
expires 30s;
}
Examples – Standardizing the Domain Name
One of the most common uses of NGINX rewrite rules is to capture deprecated or nonstandard versions of a website’s domain name and redirect them to the current name. There are several related use cases.Redirecting from a Former Name to the Current Name
This sample NGINX rewrite rule permanently redirects requests from www.old‑name.com and old‑name.com to www.new‑name.com, using two NGINX variables to capture values from the original request URL –$scheme
is the original protocol (http or https) and $request_uri
is the full URI (following the domain name), including arguments:server {
listen 80;
listen 443 ssl;
server_name www.old-name.com old-name.com;
return 301 $scheme://www.new-name.com$request_uri;
}
Because $request_uri
captures the portion of the URL
that follows the domain name, this rewrite is suitable if there’s a
one‑to‑one correspondence of pages between the old and new sites (for
example, www.new‑name.com/about has the same basic content as www.old‑name.com/about).
If you’ve reorganized the site in addition to changing the domain name,
it might be safer to redirect all requests to the home page instead, by
omitting $request_uri
:server {
listen 80;
listen 443 ssl;
server_name www.old-name.com old-name.com;
return 301 $scheme://www.new-name.com;
}
Some other blogs about rewriting URLs in NGINX use the rewrite
directive for these use cases, like this:# NOT RECOMMENDED
rewrite ^ $scheme://www.new-name.com$request_uri permanent;
This is less efficient than the equivalent return
directive, because it requires NGINX to process a regular expression, albeit a simple one (the caret [ ^
], which matches the complete original URL). The corresponding return
directive is also easier for a human reader to interpret: return
301
more clearly indicates that NGINX returns code 301
than the rewrite
...
permanent
notation does.Adding and Removing the www Prefix
These examples add and remove the www prefix:# add 'www'
server {
listen 80;
listen 443 ssl;
server_name domain.com;
return 301 $scheme://www.domain.com$request_uri;
}
# remove 'www'
server {
listen 80;
listen 443 ssl;
server_name www.domain.com;
return 301 $scheme://domain.com$request_uri;
}
Again, return
is preferable to the equivalent rewrite
, which follows. The rewrite
requires interpreting a regular expression – ^(.*)$
– and creating a custom variable ($1
) that in fact is equivalent to the built‑in $request_uri
variable.# NOT RECOMMENDED
rewrite ^(.*)$ $scheme://www.domain.com$1 permanent;
Redirecting All Traffic to the Correct Domain Name
Here’s a special case that redirects incoming traffic to the website’s home page when the request URL doesn’t match anyserver
and location
blocks, perhaps because the domain name is misspelled. It works by combining the default_server
parameter to the listen
directive and the underscore as the parameter to the server_name
directive.server {
listen 80 default_server;
listen 443 ssl default_server;
server_name _;
return 301 $scheme://www.domain.com;
}
We use the underscore as the parameter to server_name
to
avoid inadvertently matching a real domain name – it’s safe to assume
that no site will ever have the underscore as its domain name. Requests
that don’t match any other server
blocks in the configuration end up here, though, and the default_server
parameter to listen
tells NGINX to use this block for them. By omitting the $request_uri
variable from the rewritten URL, we redirect all requests to the home
page, a good idea because requests with the wrong domain name are
particularly likely to use URIs that don’t exist on the website.Example – Forcing all Requests to Use SSL/TLS
Thisserver
block forces all visitors to use a secured (SSL/TLS) connection to your site.server {
listen 80;
server_name www.domain.com;
return 301 https://www.domain.com$request_uri;
}
Some other blogs about NGINX rewrite rules use an if
test and the rewrite
directive for this use case, like this:# NOT RECOMMENDED
if ($scheme != "https") {
rewrite ^ https://www.mydomain.com$uri permanent;
}
But this method takes extra processing because NGINX must both evaluate the if
condition and process the regular expression in the rewrite
directive.Example – Enabling Pretty Permalinks for WordPress Websites
NGINX and NGINX Plus are very popular application delivery platforms for websites that use WordPress. The followingtry_files
directive tells NGINX to check for the existence of a file, $uri
, and then directory, $uri/
. If neither the file or directory exists, NGINX returns a redirect to /index.php and passes the query‑string arguments, which are captured by the $args
parameter.location / {
try_files $uri $uri/ /index.php?$args;
}
Example – Dropping Requests for Unsupported File Extensions
For various reasons, your site might receive request URLs that end in a file extension corresponding to an application server you’re not running. In this example from the Engine Yard blog, the application server is Ruby on Rails, so requests with file types handled by other application servers (Active Server Pages, PHP, CGI, and so on) cannot be serviced and need to be rejected. In aserver
block that passes any requests for dynamically generated assets to the app, this location
directive drops requests for non‑Rails file types before they hit the Rails queue.location ~ \.(aspx|php|jsp|cgi)$ {
return 410;
}
Strictly speaking, response code 410
(Gone)
is intended for situations when the requested resource used to be
available at this URL but is no longer, and the server does not know its
current location, if any. Its advantage over response code 404
is that it explicitly indicates the resource is permanently unavailable, so clients won’t send the request again.You might want to provide clients with a more accurate indication of the reason for the failure, by returning response code
403
(Forbidden)
and an explanation such as "Server
handles
only
Ruby
requests"
as the text string. As an alternative, the deny
all
directive returns 403
without an explanation:location ~ \.(aspx|php|jsp|cgi)$ {
deny all;
}
Code 403
implicitly confirms that the requested resource exists, so code 404
might be the better choice if you want to achieve “security through
obscurity” by providing the client with as little information as
possible. The downside is that clients might repeatedly retry the
request because 404
does not indicate whether the failure is temporary or permanent.Example – Configuring Custom Rerouting
In this example from MODXCloud, you have a resource that functions as a controller for a set of URLs. Your users can use a more readable name for a resource, and you rewrite (not redirect) it to be handled by the controller at listing.html.rewrite ^/listings/(.*)$ /listing.html?listing=$1 last;
As an example, the user‑friendly URL http://mysite.com/listings/123 is rewritten to a URL handled by the listing.html controller, http://mysite.com/listing.html?listing=123
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét